process/gaps/GAP-L2-P1-mcptransport-status-attribute-undeclared
GAP-L2-P1-mcptransport-status-attribute-undeclared reference
ontology-schema.yaml defines MCPTransport with attributes: id, displayName, kind, specUrl. The example streamable-http.yaml uses two extra fields: specVersion: "2025-03-26" and status: live. These are not declared in the NodeKind. This breaks V-12.5 (NodeKind ↔ examples must be consistent).
Continue reading
Nearby pages in the same section.
GAP-L2-P1-mcptransport-status-attribute-undeclared
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| id | gap:mcptransport-status-attribute-undeclared |
| title | MCPTransport.status / specVersion fields used in examples but not declared in NodeKind |
| level | 2 |
| priority | P1 |
| discoveredAt | 2026-04-28T00:00:00Z |
| source | grep MCPTransport in ontology-schema.yaml vs examples |
| status | closed |
| owner | tbd |
Current state
ontology-schema.yaml defines MCPTransport with attributes: id, displayName, kind, specUrl. The example streamable-http.yaml uses **two extra fields**: specVersion: "2025-03-26" and status: live. These are not declared in the NodeKind. This breaks V-12.5 (NodeKind ↔ examples must be consistent).
Desired state
Add specVersion: string and status: enum<live,deprecated,community,draft> to the MCPTransport NodeKind definition, OR remove them from the examples.
Evidence
- C:/work/v6/graph/schema/ontology-schema.yaml lines 139-152
- C:/work/v6/graph/schema/examples/compute/mcp-transports/streamable-http.yaml
Propagation status
- Level 2: open
Propagation chain
- Level 2: 1 attribute addition each on NodeKind + transport.md update.
Notes
Same root cause as GAP-L1-P2-mcp-stdio-vs-http-sse-deprecation but framed as Level 2 internal-consistency.
Resolution (2026-04-28)
Closed. MCPTransport NodeKind in ontology-schema.yaml now declares specVersion: string, specRevisions: list<string>, currentSpecRevision: string, streaming: enum<none,partial,full>, and status: enum<live,deprecated,community,draft>. All four example YAMLs (stdio, streamable-http, http-sse, websocket) conform.